Caleb's eyes widen and his face heats up. He drops the menu and doesn't even hear the thing about magic or whatever, because...what?

"Needs a fuck?" Caleb blurts out, an echo of disbelief. He doesn't even know how to ask. "Gabe, uh...sleeps around?"

He can't believe it. He can't believe Gabe. Gabe said that thing in the paper was a lie, that there hadn't been anyone else. Why would Gabe lie to him?